WHERE SUCCESSFUL ADVERTISING MEETS LGBT EQUALITY

Budget Rent A Car Corp., Disco

Members:

In this ongoing award winning self-reflexive campaign, ad agency executives sit in a board room trying to come up with an ad idea. Past installments showed the ad "ideas" ending up in a violent end for the consumer (chased by bears, car accidents) and were "discarded."

This installment is less violent and instead goes for a campy, 1970s Village People-type stereotype. It starts off with the agency executives talking about how Budget Rent A Car "is working really hard to improve truck rental." (Indeed, it is the first commercial behind that service for the company.) They mention the new option of movers helping load and unload the trucks.

One woman asks, "Can we make 'load and unload' even better?" Her colleague answers, "Roller skates. To make the move even faster."

Suddenly, in a fantasy of how it might look, to the recast tune of "Shame" by Evelyn "Champagne" King, five rather tacky men in blue Budget T-shirts on roller skates shimmy and shake as if they were on the floor of a disco. Except they're on a sunny suburban street next to a rental truck, and there are no women.

The T-shirts all expose stomachs, some bigger than others -- one shirt is torn, another is tied in middle, and the third simply cannot contain the large stomach behind it. They all wear too-tight denim short-shorts. A male skater picks another up by the waist and spins him around like a woman.

Suddenly, after that vision passes them, the ad agency team immediately dismisses the concept.

This over-the-top ad in an over-the-top campaign nevertheless ties disco to effeminate dancing men -- the sole joke of the commercial. It's not exactly the only reason roller skates might be a bad idea for movers.

User Comments
Max Shultz
What offends me about this commercial is that the ad execs clearly did not want to hire gay men. So, the ad execs decided not to use rollerskates, because they feared it would make their employees gay, or attract gay men who seek their employment. That is employment discrimination, and not something to be taken lightly.

TJ Singleton
I don't see the anti-gay subtext. It's making fun of roller disco, and that's it. I enjoyed the commercial.

Steve
I don't view this ad as negative at all...I thought it was rather funny.

Lisa
The main guy in this video is a very good friend of mine. He is a very hetero father of two that owns a roller rink in San Diego. He has skated in many movies and has ties with the media. The commercial was timed to ride the renewed interest in rollerskating, and was supposed to be a funny spoof of the old roller disco days. It wasn't meant to be gay anything.

Bryce
If anything, I found this more a parody of bad drag and not homophobia. The men were stereotyped, but in such a manner that is so campy you would not take it serious. When the ad switched back to the meeting room, no one seemed to have a creepy look on their faces, but just looked at each other like it was a bad idea, which in all fairness, really is a bad idea.

Todd Hill
Taken in the context of Budget's other ads in this series, I think this was the least objectionable and the least grisly. I really took it as more of a parody of the '70s and the roller-disco era than anything else. Who's to say the movers are being portrayed as gay? From what I could tell, they are just movers who happen to be male and who, for the purposes of embodying and illustrating cheesy '70s disco-roller culture, happen to be doing all the dance moves so typical (for men and women, gay or straight) of that (regrettable!!!) era. I thought it was a funny ad and fit well into their on-going theme.

Mac
I think it was campy and funny. Don't be so thin skinned! We should all be able to laugh at ourselves and others.

Laird Ehlert
The men looked straight to me!

werewolffan
Well, I think that the men are cute.

Cutter McCoy
Actually, I think that it's just as sad that the Commercial Closet editors pay attention to the fact that several of the t-shirt clad skaters feature stomachs that were "past their prime." It seems that while homophobia is unacceptable, sizeism and body fascism are still perfectly acceptable in their eyes. How is ridiculing those with less than "perfect" bodies any different from expressing outrage over insinuated homophobia?

Scott Olson
This ad was not offensive to me as a gay man. These men did not fit the gay stereotype. What was funny in this commercial was the juxtaposition of fairly unattractive / uncoordinated men doing these sorts of roller-disco moves. The roller-disco was never associated with being gay as the overview stated. If you come to that conclusion, it's because you already have that stereotype in your head.

Dean Morris
(The editor's) comments are superficial and lack a sense of humor, as well as fear humor in the form of self-effacement. Advertisers know there is enough delight in chubs and bears to keep your attention in a silly way while in the meeting they reject idea only because it's not superficially Old-Fashioned Pretty. Real ad people aren't angels but seem to know more about deeper delights than you, writing and prejudging these spots.

Cheryl
As a product of the disco era, this commercial brought back memories for me. The song was not by the Village People - the background music was "Shame" by Evelyn Champagne King, an R&B artist from the early 1980's. I think Budget truck rental wanted to get its message out about its new commitment to customer service - assistance in loading vehicles. The guys were a little on the extreme side. I think it was a good attempt to maket relocation services for the upwardly mobile GLBT community. Hopefully their future efforts will be better.

Terrence
This ad is unsuccessful and offensive. I think that the men are obviously portrayed as gay, unattractive, and otherwise. What really makes no sense in this ad is the total disconnect between the real perils of using roller skates and the over slipping, falling and dropping of items. Yes it's camp and cheesy, and some would say playful and non offensive, but what is the point? In this case it seems the only point is to parody disco roller skating at the expense of gay men. It is a cheap shot that seeks only to make the straight audience feel uncomfortable with these gay men. Further, it perpetuates the stereotype that gay men are flamboyant.

Gavlas
To be honest, this ad seemed to be more of a parody of "sexy girl troupe" promoters than of effeminate or transsexual men.

Gen
I am not as sensitive as I could be, but I can see how it subtly shows the negative gay image nearly everyone has. If the ad execs in the commercial wanted to show the bad outcome of rollerskates, they could have shown the movers slipping and sliding around, and dropping furniture, or rolling down the hill, etc. Associating roller skates with disco, and also homosexuality, and leading to the execs rejecting that idea based on solely that (it was a bad idea anyway, but not for that reason) subtly teaches others that gay peoople are flamboyant and fit into a stereotype. It's everywhere, but it isn't particularly offensive. It's just subtle, and stereotypical. There are stereotypes like this for everyone. All put together, it leads to people assuming things about other people and ignorance.

Rick Bickmore
The little dance routine wasn't a pretty picture, and the ad execs didn't want to go there. But the men themselves were far removed from any gay stereotype in their build, haircuts, etc. Only their queeny behavior could be called "stereotypically gay". It just didn't strike me as a negative ad,
and left me laughing, not grumbling.